eyes4earth.org
Consciousness for Connectedness
  • Home
  • About
  • What is…?
    • Meaningful Nature Experience
    • Connectedness with Nature
    • nature-based synchronicity
  • Research
    • PhD Dissertation
    • Research Insights
    • Bibliography
    • Helpful Links
  • Publications
  • Experiences
    • Fauna (Animals)
    • Flora & Landscape
    • Share Your Own!
  • Poetry
  • Media
    • Video
    • Music
    • Images
  • Blog
Blog 1

Owls with Orders

By Matthew Zylstra @eyes4earth · On July 27, 2022

The most viewed article on eyes4earth.org is one I wrote over a decade ago called “Don’t Kill the Messenger“. It still gets plenty of reads and I was recently contacted by a European journalist who had also encountered it during his research for a German language article he wanted to write about the persecution of owls in many parts of Africa.

Very little of what I shared with him as response to his questions made it into the final article (see German version below) so I thought I would share some of my responses here re where I stand on the issue:

Q: Has the superstition surrounding owls in South Africa contributed to some species’ endangerment? In which way?

In some areas of South Africa these behaviours threaten local or regional owl populations, but the (meta-)population of most species across South Africa is in a reasonable state, although in general decline. Whilst I obviously cannot condone owl killings for whatever reason,  I do think we need to place the mortality due to superstition in context:  habitat loss/degradation, electrical power lines, roadside collisions and climate change are arguably much larger threats to owls.  For example, two of the most vulnerable owl species in South Africa – the Grass Owl and Pel’s Fishing Owl  – are most threatened by grassland disturbance and river siltation and pollution, respectively.   I also wonder how many species have been helped (i.e. left alone, respected or protected) by so-called “superstition” over the years. We will probably never know the answer, although there is good evidence that “sacred natural sites” and “sacred animals (e.g. totems)” can benefit conservation and biodiversity outcomes.  So it can work both ways.

Q: How could those myths be curbed in order to save the owls’ reputation?

I am not convinced the myths should be curbed per se.  More than ever, global nature needs powerful stories and emotive appeal to help humanity curb its destruction. Reducing nature to the materialist language of “resources” for consumptive benefit and capital gain is arguably more damaging than instilling it with the myth, magic and meaning characterised by more intact non-Westernised cultures. The “problem” of “superstition” is often the result of a traditional belief that has lost its original systems context and the ecological knowledge that accompanied it.  (Although note that owls are subject to similar beliefs across many cultures, globally, including European folklore)

So rather than an “educate them” directive , which tends to elevate the Western (scientific) worldview as being better and the other as inferior or ignorant, I would rather encourage “engagement”: that is, understanding the nature of the problem in the local context by listening to fears/concerns and having empathetic conservations that sensitively present options and alternatives in favour of the owl and its beneficial role in the local ecology.  This may also involve questions which invite different interpretations of the belief, e.g. “Is the owl responsible for your bad luck is it a simply a messenger or warning for bad luck that may befall you?”

This article contains approaches that I support, if delivered with sensitivity.

As conservationists, I don’t think we can pick and choose which part of a cultural belief system we want, and which we wish to reject.  And we certainly cannot reject an entire cultural worldview simply on the basis of specific elements we find uncomfortable. Similarly, we need to interrogate our own (Western) worldviews and how that also contributes to species persecution. We need to realise that some non-Western worldviews, however awkward in parts, could well become much-needed allies in inspiring nature conservation into the future.

My views here are my own and not necessarily that of my affiliations. Thank you.

Owls with Orders

AfricaHuman-Wildlife InteractionTraditional Knowledge
Share Tweet

Matthew Zylstra

Matthew Zylstra, PhD is an ecologist, lecturer and facilitator focusing on human~nature connectedness. His transdisciplinary research has entwined ecology, environmental psychology, and education in support of deep learning and wellbeing. He is a keen naturalist, especially in coastal and marine ecosystems.  Matthew’s PhD dissertation on meaningful nature experience, nature connectedness and its role in transformative education is freely available for download here »

You Might Also Like

  • Cleaning space for the argonauts

  • Intentions in print

  • Up close & personal

1 Comment

  • Annie Olson says: July 22, 2023 at 4:06 am

    Hi Matthew,
    Great to meet you yesterday 7/20/23 on the zoom Nature coincidence. I shared about my Great Horned Owl experience. So I was delighted today to read these articles on Owls. synchronicity continues. Thank you for what you’re doing.

    This will prompt me to write the full story of this Owl family

    Reply
  • Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Recent Posts

    • Webinar Reply: Coincidences & Compassion

      August 16, 2023
    • The nature of Nature Coincidences

      July 19, 2023
    • Estuarine Experiences

      July 7, 2023

    Instagram Feed

    This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

    Error: No feed found.

    Please go to the Instagram Feed settings page to create a feed.

    Follow On Facebook

    Topics / Tags

    Africa Americas Attention Birds Cetaceans Community Outreach Consciousness CWN Education Human-Wildlife Interaction Insects Interspecies Communication Interviews Mammals Marine MNE Non-Native Species Oceania Perception Poetry Sensory Awareness Spirituality Synchronicity Traditional Knowledge Video Wilderness

    Follow On Twitter

    My Tweets

    Meaningful Quotes

    … Rationalism and the Enlightenment are not points on a continuum of progress but simply two species of wisdom.

    — Barry Lopez (2003)
    • Contact
    • Privacy
    • Archive

    About

    eyes4earth.org is a portal into meaningful nature experience and connectedness with nature. It draws on scientific research and experiential insight to explore implications for sustainability education and consciousness.
    Learn more »

    PhD Download

    The PhD research underpinning certain content on eyes4earth.org was completed in early 2014.

    The final dissertation is freely available for download here.

    Learn more »

    GIVE

    eyes4earth supports masiyembo.org: an initiative that is creating opportunities for people to find meaning and wellbeing through nature. Join us in giving others the chance to experience renewed connection with earth.Donate via GivenGain


    © 2007-2021 eyes4earth.org